Your cart

Cookie & Cake Butters - Butter Up! Collection

From Monster Cookie to Black Velvet to Cookies N Cream, our butters are a rainbow of heavenly flavors! Try one - try 'em all!
Black Velvet Cake Butter

Save
$8.40

Black Velvet Cake Butter — $23.59 +
Courtesy @kmathewson_fit
Brownie Butter — $32.99 +
Chippy ChocoNut Cake Butter

Save
$8.40

Chippy ChocoNut Cake Butter — $23.59 +
Cookies ‘n Cream Cookie Butter
Cookies ‘n Cream Cookie Butter — $31.99 +
Gift Card
Gift Card — $10 +
Monster Cookie Butter
Monster Cookie Butter — $34.99 +
Ripped Red Velvet Cake Butter
Ripped Red Velvet Cake Butter — $31.99 +