Cookie & Cake Butters - Butter Up! Collection

From Monster Cookie to Black Velvet to Cookies N Cream, our butters are a rainbow of heavenly flavors! Try one - try 'em all!

ALL NEW!! Cake Butter - COOKIES N CREAM GLUTEN-FREE (AND ON SALE!)

Save
$8

ALL NEW!! Cake Butter - COOKIES N CREAM GLUTEN-FREE (AND ON SALE!) — $25

Cake Butter - BLACK VELVET

Save
$1.50

Cake Butter - BLACK VELVET — $5.50 +

Courtesy @kmathewson_fit

Save
$8

Cake Butter - BROWNIE BUTTER — $25 +

Cake Butter - CHIPPY CHOCO-NUT

Save
$1.50

Cake Butter - CHIPPY CHOCO-NUT — $5.50 +

Cake Butter - COOKIES 'N CREAM

Save
$8

Cake Butter - COOKIES 'N CREAM — $25 +

Cake Butter - MONSTER COOKIE

Save
$8

Cake Butter - MONSTER COOKIE — $25 +

Cake Butter - MORE S'MORES

Save
$1.50

Cake Butter - MORE S'MORES — $5.50 +

Cake Butter - RIPPED RED VELVET

Save
$1.50

Cake Butter - RIPPED RED VELVET — $5.50 +

Gift Card — $10 +